Manga spoilers for Files 1154–1156, including the culprit and Matsuda’s confession.
Who killed Kurumi Nishiei in Detective Conan File 1156?
Did Jinpei Matsuda really propose to Chihaya?
Sumika Jujo is the culprit, and a water-filled plastic bag exposes her attempt to recover the ring. File 1156, The Magic Ring Trick, concludes the Hakone hot spring case that began in File 1154. The same trick also explains how Matsuda once found Chihaya’s ring—and turned the discovery into a confession.
The ring-on-the-finger scene has the feel of a youthful proposal, but the chapter depicts a confession and a request for a date, not an accepted engagement. The relationship analysis below stays within this case.
Who is the culprit, and why does she return for the ring?
The solution begins with Jujo trying to retrieve something she cannot safely leave behind. After the ring search, the three suspects are bathing: former club ace Reiko Shibukawa, former club president Tamie Ichiki, and former vice president Sumika Jujo.
They discuss the silent phone calls and nuisance emails that began after Katsuto married, suggesting a stalker might be responsible. Shibukawa and Ichiki leave to tell the police. Jujo stays behind.
She takes a plastic bag hidden between a chair and a basin, fills it with water, and lowers it into the muddy bath. She puts her foot inside and searches the bottom. When she finds the ring, Chihaya confronts her.
“So it really was you!” (unofficial translation)
The ring is more than a missing possession. It is likely to carry blood spatter, so recovering it matters to the culprit’s attempt to conceal the crime. Chihaya has anticipated the retrieval method and catches Jujo using it.
How the plastic bag reveals the ring
The bag provides a clear view through water that would otherwise hide the bottom. Chihaya suspects Jujo will use the transparent bag that held her underwear. Filled with water and lowered into the muddy bath, it lets her look through the bag to locate the ring.
The trick is simple enough to connect the two timelines without a long technical explanation. Jujo uses it to recover potential evidence; Matsuda used a goldfish bag to retrieve a lost prize. The method is the same, but what the ring means to each person is very different.
Why another guest’s yukata carries the blood
Jujo’s yukata—the light robe worn at the hot spring—shows no blood reaction. Another guest’s robe carries Kurumi’s blood instead. The robe has changed wearers; the blood has not disappeared.
Jujo wrapped her body in toilet paper before the murder so that the paper would catch the blood spatter. She then put on her yukata, but some blood still transferred to it. In the changing room, she waited for a guest with a similar build and exchanged robes with her. Bathing would wash the blood from Jujo’s body.
That sequence explains the apparently misplaced bloodstain. It also leaves a way to connect Jujo to the other guest’s robe: her sweat and skin traces remain on the fabric. The solution brings together the ring she tries to recover and the clothing she tries to disown, rather than relying on her suspicious behavior alone.
The motive: a love letter that never reached its recipient
Jujo believes the wedding ring should have been hers. The day before their high school graduation ceremony, she wrote Katsuto a love letter and asked her best friend Kurumi to deliver it. Kurumi told her that Katsuto already liked someone else, and Jujo believed that ended her chance with him.
At a later reunion, Jujo learns that Katsuto had liked her too and had prepared a letter for her. Kurumi had separately told him that Jujo liked someone else. Both were persuaded to give up through the same intermediary.
To Jujo, Kurumi had deliberately distorted two people’s feelings. That betrayal explains her resentment and the significance she attaches to the ring; it does not justify the murder. Her claim that the ring was meant for her is the motive she gives, rather than proof that the two would certainly have married.
Chihaya challenges Jujo for leaving the expression of her feelings to somebody else. She then recalls a very different way of declaring love: Matsuda kept speaking for himself, even when Chihaya rejected him.
“I know someone like that. A fool who kept confessing even after getting rejected again and again…” (unofficial translation)
The transition makes the flashback part of the case’s emotional argument. One relationship was derailed by messages passed through another person. Matsuda’s approach leaves Chihaya in no doubt about whose feelings she is hearing.
Matsuda’s confession: why the ring feels like a proposal
Matsuda turns finding the ring into a direct confession. In the high school flashback, Chihaya drops a ring won at a shooting gallery into a muddy puddle. Matsuda uses a bag containing goldfish to find it. By the time he draws her attention to her left hand, the ring is on her ring finger.
“Chihaya! There’s something on your left hand.” (unofficial translation)
“I like you, Chihaya…” (unofficial translation)
He offers to explain the trick in exchange for a date.
“I can tell you how I found it… but in exchange… go on a date with me!” (unofficial translation)
Chihaya replies that she would rather not know. Kenji Hagiwara then explains how the goldfish bag allows a clear view through the muddy water. Chihaya eventually tells Matsuda that she will go to a movie with him as a reward.
The pleasure of the scene lies in that exchange. Matsuda tries to turn his ingenuity into a romantic opportunity; Chihaya refuses his terms; Hagiwara supplies the explanation anyway. The movie invitation gives Matsuda something to look forward to without making Chihaya’s response an acceptance of everything he wants.
The ring finger and the confession make the scene feel like a schoolboy proposal. It is a romantic gesture, not confirmation of an engagement or an established couple. Keeping that distinction does not make the scene less charming. His feelings are unmistakable, while her answer preserves the teasing distance between them.
How the case and the flashback illuminate each other
The shared ring-finding trick connects two contrasting responses to love. Jujo returns to a ring bound up with betrayal and a future she believes was taken from her. Matsuda places a recovered ring on Chihaya’s finger while telling her directly how he feels.
That contrast gives the chapter more substance than a murder solution followed by an unrelated romantic memory. Chihaya’s criticism of Jujo leads naturally to Matsuda: he is her example of someone who would not let another person speak for him.
The case does not establish that persistence guarantees love, and Chihaya still gets to reject Matsuda’s request. The contrast concerns how feelings are communicated, not an entitlement to have them returned. Her eventual willingness to see a movie with him is a small, specific response; it should not be expanded into an unwritten relationship history.
Across Files 1154–1156, Matsuda’s directness gives the flashback its appeal. The chapter’s warmest moment is also its clearest: he takes responsibility for saying what he means. That is why the memory fits the solution so well.
Why Jugo sees Matsuda as a rival even now
After the case, Jugo Yokomizo notices Chihaya lost in thought. He asks what she said to make the culprit fall quiet. Chihaya answers with a reference to Matsuda.
“Just an old story about a huge fool named Jinpei Matsuda…” (unofficial translation)
Jugo inwardly regards Matsuda as a formidable rival even though he is dead. His jealousy shows how strongly Chihaya’s memory of Matsuda affects the present scene. Matsuda cannot participate in this conversation, yet mentioning his name changes how Jugo reads it.
That gives the ending its bittersweet humor. Jugo is reacting to a memory he cannot compete with in the ordinary way. His reaction may hint at further movement between him and Chihaya, but it does not confirm where that relationship will go, or define all of Chihaya’s feelings toward Matsuda.
At this chapter’s publication, the forthcoming 2026 movie Fallen Angel of the Highway offered a possible place to explore those relationships. That was speculation prompted by the chapter, not evidence of what the finished film confirms. File 1156 itself leaves us with Jugo’s jealousy and Chihaya’s lingering memory.
Reading the surrounding chapters
File 1156 closes the hot spring case; the adjacent chapters provide its setup and what follows. The File 1155 article below covers the preceding stage of the ring mystery. The File 1157 article continues beyond this conclusion.


Further reading (contains spoilers): Jinpei Matsuda's death and relationships and Chihaya Hagiwara and Jugo Yokomizo's relationship.

Comments